982-1

Hands On: Icy Dock MB982SPR-2S SATA HDD/SSD Converter

Introduction

Many users of Windows Home Server v1 like to run their system drive in a RAID 1 array.  While the Shares in v1 were “protected” from a disk failure through the use of Drive Extender and duplication, the system drive was not.  If you lost the system drive, rebuilding your server could be a very laborious task, particularly if you did not have an external backup of your data.

Hence the desire to run the system drive in a RAID array.

Windows Home Server 2011 has changed that need to create a system RAID array, as one can now produce an external backup of the operating system.  However, if one were to experience a OS drive failure, you would still have to restore the system before having access to the server again.

So, while it is nice to have a system backup option, a RAID option for the system drive is still desirable to many.

With WHS 2011, and the loss of DE, you have many drive redundancy options available to you.  There are many flavors of RAID to consider for the entire drive array.  There are, for either version of WHS, the option (or requirement) for external backups.

For those who desire system protection, but who do not want to deal with a full RAID setup on all their server drives, I have an alternative you just might want to consider: the Icy Dock MB982SPR-2S.

This solution is still RAID, so you might ask why.  The answer is simple:

  • setting up a 2-drive RAID 1 array is incredibly easy.
  • since the MB982SPR-2S uses 2.5” drives, you don’t lose a drive bay to that second drive.

This product has been available for some time, but it was not on my radar until recently when I acquired a pair of 2.5” drives.  My interest in this product increased significantly at that point.

Whether you consider this a viable option for your use is up to you, but before you decide, you might want to check out how this device works.


Enjoyed this post? Share it.

If you enjoyed reading this post, then why not share it with your friends and followers?

About Jim Clark

Hello. I’m from the heartland of the U.S. Lots of corn and beans, although Iowa is a lot more than just farmland. It also has a few computer enthusiasts (no, not me!). I’ve been around PCs since I got my 1st PC XT aloooong time ago. WGS is one of the first sites I found centered around WHS. And the best. Every once in awhile, I do get away from the KB and enjoy time with and my wife and our 4 kids. And I do have a day job.

Sign Up for WGS Daily News

If you don't want to miss out on the latest news from We Got Served, why not subscribe to our daily digest? You'll get the day's headlines and a short summary of each news item delivered straight to your inbox each morning.

, , , , , , ,

  • Rychek

    Nice review Jim! I didn't know a device like that existed. Now I'm going to have to find a need for one. :D

    • Jim_Clark

      Where there is a techie (you and me!), there is a need! :)

  • derausgewanderte

    Jim, if I have an existing WHS11 installation and would like to swap the drive with this configuration, is it possible to image the current WHS11 installation over to the new Raid1 drive-set and WHS11 stays functional?
    cool setup, a little on the expensive side (2x$60-70 plus $74 ~ $200) but less painful in a system drive failure scenario.

    • Jim_Clark

      I see no reason why you couldn't. As the RAID setup is (in effect) transparent to the operating system, utilities such as Acronis should have no problem. Of course, I have not tested that…

      You could get a couple of smaller drives, but I do not think you would save that much. And $74 for the module seems quite inexpensive considering what you are getting for that $74.

  • Peter

    I have this running in my new WHS 2011 now for a week or so and everything seems very happy.
    I had a 500GB Seagate Momentus 7200.4 lying around so bought a second one of those. Install was easy and it just works.
    Still trying to figure my mail alert settings, probably just some sill SMTP setting I have wrong.
    Let's hope it really works when it's needed. One of those insurance policies you wish you never need.

  • Jim_Clark

    As a RAID 1 array is simply a mirror of each other, you should be able to pull a drive and stick into any other machine. Just to absolutely certain, I pulled a drive and stuck it in this computer. All looks good!

  • Mark

    Thanks Jim!

  • Patrick Greene

    Glad Icy dock came out with a model like this, the 'other' company that made these seems to not be able to stock them very well. We use RAID 1 at work all the time, another 'feature' is that we pull one drive when doing upgrades etc, if it 'goes bad' we revert to the earlier version on the drive we pulled. If all is good, we reinsert the pulled drive and let it rebuild.

    One question Jim, the RAID configuration 'dial' cannot just be preset? It has to be changed while powered up? Seems strange to me if so.

    Thank you for the detailed review.

    • Jim_Clark

      From the manual (abbreviated):
      1. power down
      2. set mode on dial
      3. press reset button while powering up the system
      and on from there.

      #3 is the gotcha… :(

  • Patrick Greene

    Jim, thanks for the response. Didn't mean to doubt you. I noticed from the various reviews that it seems this had been on the market before, withdrawn to be 'tweaked' and reissued. I noticed also they had a firmware update to fix a problem with SSDs.

  • dennis

    Hi Jim, one question on the device while running in RAID1 – can the system be set to boot up from the RAID1 array? (ie. installing Win7/linux/etc and simply booting from it?)

    • Jim_Clark

      If I understand your question correctly, yes. Exactly what I did starting of Page 5.