d1

Hands On: Data Robotics Drobo FS NAS

Conclusions and Costs

After looking at the Drobo FS, many of the NAS units I have had the opportunity to take a look at over the past year I feel I could reclassify as Network Attached Servers.  When I say server, I refer to the software features such as

  • *Direct* Remote Access.  Although the FS is remotely accessible through mapped drives on a client machine, like a WHS.
  • Website creation
  • bittorrent services
  • Media services
  • IP camera services
  • Print server
  • Backup services
  • External drive management  (no external devices can be added).
  • iSCSI.  If you need iSCSI, you need the DroboElite or DroboPro.
  • and more.

The Drobo Dashboard seems quite underwhelming, however it includes everything you need to perform basic NAS management, and it does it in a very efficient manner.  If you need more, many of those services can be added through the use of DroboApps.  But the Drobo FS is pure Network Attached Storage.  Nothing less and only as much beyond that as desired.  If you are looking for a full featured Network Attached Server out of the box, you may be disappointed by the Drobo FS. 

In the end, if you are looking for a central network storage device without any extraneous bells and whistles, the Drobo FS may be the perfect choice.  About the only feature that I would like to see as a native application is some type of client backup solution.

Then we have BeyondRAID.  From where I sit as a Windows Home Server advocate, it is quite easy to really like this particular feature of the Drobo FS.  One of the most attractive features that drew me to a WHS in the first place was the mix-and-match HD capability.  Need more storage?  Add a HD, any HD.  The Drobo FS has this same basic mix-and-match capability.  While the WHS DE technology redundancy is basically a RAID 1 solution, the BeyondRAID technology uses a more efficient (HD capacity-wise) RAID 5 or 6 redundancy.  If you have an adequate number of drives attached.

Hardware-wise, I cannot complain, as the Drobo FS just feels solidly built.  And it is always nice to turn a computer on and hear… silence.  They include the little things, such as a Cat 6 Ethernet cable, that indicate they do not cut corners to save a few pennies on cost.

But we are at the end and we need to answer that most important question of all: how much does this device cost?  From the US side, one can obtain various configurations from Newegg.

From the UK side, one can obtain a diskless model for £495.00 from Amazon UK.

More info: Data Robotics | Drobo FS


Enjoyed this post? Share it.

If you enjoyed reading this post, then why not share it with your friends and followers?

About Jim Clark

Hello. I’m from the heartland of the U.S. Lots of corn and beans, although Iowa is a lot more than just farmland. It also has a few computer enthusiasts (no, not me!). I’ve been around PCs since I got my 1st PC XT aloooong time ago. WGS is one of the first sites I found centered around WHS. And the best. Every once in awhile, I do get away from the KB and enjoy time with and my wife and our 4 kids. And I do have a day job.

Sign Up for WGS Daily News

If you don't want to miss out on the latest news from We Got Served, why not subscribe to our daily digest? You'll get the day's headlines and a short summary of each news item delivered straight to your inbox each morning.

, , , ,

  • boggy4062

    As much money Microsoft dumps on different acquisitions, I have never understood, why not on Drobo technology (specially, after the WHS launch). Drobo used to be USB 2.0, and finally they got other interfaces. The performance still does not thrill. Microsoft would have enough money and resources to tweak that part.
    What a shame…Just my 2 cents.

    • Jim_Clark

      I sure do not disagree about WHS/Drobo… :)

      • boggy4062

        Couple of thoughts on Data Robotics. There was a time that they were much more open. One could get access to their user forum, to get a feeling how the product REALLY works from the real users.

        Today?…. No such thing. Forums have disappeared from the company website, only glitzy knowledgebase and FAQ's. This doesn't pass my smell test…. if you know what I mean. The company has changed and is hiding something from potential new customers (product problems, customer support level problems,etc.)… as far as I can tell.

        Reputable companies usually are not afraid to show what real day-to-day customers think about their products. Why Data Robotics follow the industry standard?

        Not good. I am waiting for WHS v. 2 and will probably replace my old HP ex475.

  • http://www.RandomnessPhotography.com Dustin Finn

    Mr. Boggy certainly has a point and its something that has been bothering me severely. I have had so many issues with my 2 Drobo's that my complaints about Drobo on Twitter got me blocked from their Twitter account. It's really weird all the changes that have happened over there and as soon as I can get rid of my drobo's I am DONE with them.

  • Carl

    It's not all black and white, you know.

    The whole Droboshare business was their big mistake. A premature product that led to many mac-using customers losing data. And, as a consequence, closing of the forum (which of course still exists but is limited to Drobo owners). However, since then Data Robotics seem to have found the right track again, product-wise. The Drobo S and Drobo FS are great products, the FS is a vast improvement over Droboshare.

    • boggy4062

      Carl: I will assume you are responding to my criticism of Drobo, so… you are wrong. It IS very black and white in this case.
      I do care how, and if a company is trying to deal with criticism. It is actually a norm for a good, honest company to disclose to a potential new customers of any limitations, problems. Once they get your money, what is the incentive to behave? Creating a website with a "I hatedrobo.com" or "drobosucks.com"?

    • boggy4062

      … continued:

      Guess what? Data Robotics must be aware of their customers' general dissatisfaction level…. They already OWN drobosucks.com.xD… Don't y you see a problem with it? I certainly do.

      BTW, very foolish approach in the age of Internet, blogs, twitter,etc. They can block you from their twitter account, but … can they stop you from twitting all day long about sucky Drobo / Data Robotics experience? Can they stop you commenting on every relevant website or blog? Yeah …. sure…:wink::wink: ;)
      I am not mean person, but one could start a domain list of possible variations, which reflect a general displeasure of this product….Will Data Robotics buy out EVERY one of them? What is it going to do to their marketing budget expenses….hmmm B). Simply silly. Does CEO of this company realize how childish this game can become..?
      Again, my 2 cents on the subject.

  • Ross

    Thank you so much for this in-depth review. I was looking for a detailed review of the Drobo FS.

    Would you recommend the Drobo FS over an HP MediaSmart EX495?

    I run my own freelance design and visualization studio out of my house and really need to upgrade my data storage.

    My needs are:
    - File serving to PC(3), Macbook Pro, Xbox 360
    - Remote Access over Internet
    - FTP Client
    - Backup 4 computers
    - Ability to swap drives out in case of drive failure
    - Share a printer across the network (optional)
    - Need between 8-10TB of Storage

    • boggy4062

      OK… For Microsoft environment, even current Microsoft solution is hands down THE Best solution for you: much faster (make sure to implement 1Gb network), much more flexible, provides support for ALL of your needs and some (like… support for UPS graceful shutdown in case of power trouble).
      It does similar drive redundancy as Drobo, actually IMHO better, since you CAN exclude certain directories from duplications.
      HP implementation of WHS v. 1 allegedly supports Apple TimeMachine…. I cannot say anything about it. Microsoft has introduced Mac support native for Vale (version 2 of WHS) which is dues soon (????).
      Drobo may have a easier support for disk swap (hot disk swap) whereas current WHS does not (you have to reboot the box).
      So… one way (if you want sexy, easy and flexible) you could go with a combo. WHS + Drobo (eSATA, or Gb iSCSI only); forget USB This will cost your pretty penny.
      Personally, I would not go with either of them. Both HP (can't buy replacement for power supply/ motherboard; VERY disappointed!) and Data Robotics (see my remarks above) play the proprietary game WAY to much. My Vale machine is going to come from somebody else, or custom build.

  • GMA

    As a Mac user, and owner of an HP Mediasmart 490EX, I can tell you that I am very unhappy. The Time Machine implementation is very poor. As an example – my primary drive is 1TB, and I have a 1.5TB in the second bay. My backup job from my iMac is 1.3TB. It won't work. As much as data spans across the server as a general pool of drives…it will NOT backup unless the job is equal to or less than the available space on the primary drive. It took me months to get to this conclusion after struggling with it. I also had great hopes for WHS as far as a Tivo server with their plugin. This has also dissapointed me due to all of the hands on management of the media (mainly due to Tivo, not WHS). As much as I want to love it…and do for many things it can do, I can't recommend it due to the Time Machine limitation using Macs. I think I'm going to eBay it and go Drobo FS…unless somebody can concvince me otherwise with a workaround. The simplicity of just adding drives, in any order, pulling small ones out and slapping in larger capacities with no data loss is pretty incredible to me…

    • boggy4062

      Just one question – as you do your backup, do you use share duplication for you backups? If you do, it all makes sense….

  • Don

    Hi I am new to all of this can I use this together with my Whs? I have to many external
    Hard drives hooked up to Whs now. The reason I ask this is because I read some thing
    that Drobo Fs could not be used with whs.
    Regards
    Don

  • Yeorwned

    The device has great hardware but is made for the absoutely dead minded user. Once you put the device on a different subnet, you can no longer manage the storage appliance. So wonderful…