HDHR20

Hands On: SiliconDust Dual-Tuner HDHomeRun

Manufacturer: SiliconDustModel: HDHomeRun Dual
List Price: $149.99Website: SiliconDust

When I think of computer TV tuners, I get this picture in my head of what one is supposed to be.  Namely, a TV tuner is either

  • PCI/PCIe
  • USB

based and connected to one computer.  I never really paid much attention to external tuner devices as they seemed more Television Connected then PC Connected devices.  I usually associated *any* external device in the same general class of such devices as TiVo, Boxee, Popcorn Hour, and others.

Perceptions can be very difficult to overcome and only the right marketing can get through to perception-impaired consumers like me.

Yes, I can be quite tunnel-visioned when need be!  During my “Transform Your Windows Home Vail Into a Media Center” series, I would keep getting these comments: Use a HDHomeRun.  It takes a while to get through to me, but I finally took a real close look at HDHomeRun and once I got past their irrational marketing concepts, I finally figured out what a HDHomeRun really is.

The HDHomeRun is an Ethernet based TV tuner.  Nothing less and nothing more.  Being Ethernet based, it has one tremendous advantage over other types of TV tuners, it can connect to any computer in your LAN (Local Area Network); not just a single computer.  It also easily gets past the PCI/PCIe and USB limitations of a virtual operating system!

In my own pathetic defense, even their own marketing people don’t seem to understand what a HDHomeRun is.

HDHR20 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

Watch – Pause – Record – HDTV
Transform any computer into a
home entertain system!

I would think that the first thing you would want to tell people is “what is this product?”!

Network-based HDTV Tuner
Turn any computer in your
home into a TV

The black-lettered marketing BS at the top says nothing about the actual product and it makes SiliconDust try to compete against the set-top cable box.  They ain’t gonna win that battle and their true competition are those PCI/PCIe and USB tuners.  The much smaller and harder-to-read white lettering comes much closer to telling it like it is.  Why are they embarrassed to tell it like it is?  If they had simply told me what their product was, my 7-part series would have been 1-part.

Enough about marketing.  I do hope you understand what a HDHomeRun truly is now (at least I do!) and it is time to move on.  Maybe…  It is most definitely time to discuss what I think is truly a great concept and a great product.

What’s In the Box

The first 2 box shots tells it all.  The marketing misdirection and the this-is-what-it-REALLY-is.

HDHR20 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun HDHR21 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

The back of the box does a great job of explaining what this product is.  Unfortunately, many a consumer may never get past the verbiage at the top of the front of the box.

HDHR22 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun HDHR23 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

It is interesting to note that most products I get for review (or even purchase) are rarely cellophane wrapped these days.  It is quite interesting to note that the HDHomeRun comes packaged that way.  Good?  Bad?  I don’t know.  It is simply an observation.

Burrowing down, we come to the contents.  Nicely packaged with the exception of one item.  The CD liner is literally glued to the packaging.  You have to remove it to get to the CD and it gets practically destroyed getting it off.

HDHR24 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

The contents, a CD (above), two coax cables, a Quick Start Guide. power cable, Ethernet cable, and

HDHR25 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

the star of the review, the HDHomeRun.

HDHR26 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun HDHR27 thumb Hands On: SiliconDust Dual Tuner HDHomeRun

   


Enjoyed this post? Share it.

If you enjoyed reading this post, then why not share it with your friends and followers?

About Jim Clark

Hello. I’m from the heartland of the U.S. Lots of corn and beans, although Iowa is a lot more than just farmland. It also has a few computer enthusiasts (no, not me!). I’ve been around PCs since I got my 1st PC XT aloooong time ago. WGS is one of the first sites I found centered around WHS. And the best. Every once in awhile, I do get away from the KB and enjoy time with and my wife and our 4 kids. And I do have a day job.

Sign Up for WGS Daily News

If you don't want to miss out on the latest news from We Got Served, why not subscribe to our daily digest? You'll get the day's headlines and a short summary of each news item delivered straight to your inbox each morning.

, , , ,

  • Rob

    I have had on of these for a few months now and have been very impressed.
    Be careful id trying to connect via wifi. You will most likely need ‘N’ rather than ‘G’ and as few walls in between as possible to ensure a smooth picture.

  • Chris Oldroyd

    I have mine connected via home plugs to my LAN and access it on G Wifi and get a few drop outs, but to be honest I love my HomeRun, its a great bit of tech

  • scoob101

    For those who have normal PCI / USB tuners, but are interested in having a Network attached tuner (like the HD Homerun), take a look at DVB LINK – it will allow you to create a tuner farm on your whs and use those tuners across the network on any machine – ecactly like a HD Homerun.
    http://mswhs.com/2010/01/22/setting-up-dvblink-onhttp://dvblogic.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=43&amp

  • otipoby

    I love my HDHR. I also have 2 ATI DCTs. During setup, I just manually add the 5 ATSC channels I care about (ABC, NBC, CBS, FOX, PBS) and then combine the ATSC channels (ie 33.1) with the cable version (ie 908) for each channel. This takes about 3 min. Win7 MCE is smart enough to prioritize the HDHR over the ATI DCTs for the channels that the HDHR gets. This way, I only use the ATI's when I absolutely have to, reducing the likelihood of running out of tuners.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/boggy4062 boggy4062

    One thing that the author did not mention, which is VERY important: make sure to upgrade to 1Gb switches / ports. 2 of dual hdHomeRuns WILL saturate your 100 Mb bandwidth (each HD channel pools 25 Mb of data). Same goes for wireless connections. You may not have a problem with a single channel on optimal G network, but 2? Good luck, I say.
    Otherwise you WILL love this device. The fact you can find keep these boxes hidden somewhere close to the antenna(s), and accessed by ANY computer at home is a real blast.

    I've been using one of these jewels for few months now, and enjoying free HD programming ever since.

  • Owl Saver

    Can I use HD Home run on a Mac? How about on an iPhone or BlackBerry?

    • http://twitter.com/CrazyPheel @CrazyPheel

      Yes, you can use it on a mac. I've used it via SageTV on the mac and elgato's eye TV software.

  • oliver

    what if you MUST have a set top box? i have an asus dual tuner EDH3-100 with two set top boxes each controlled by WMC7 and for all this i only get SD tv on one HTPC. can i use the HD home run to control set top boxes? when are we ever going to get HDTV inputs into WMC7??

  • WeeHappyPixie

    Is there a UK version that will do FreeView (DVB-T), FreeViewHD (DVB-T2) or FreeSat (DVB-S).

    Love the idea of having it on my LAN and the box hidden away.

    John

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/tezzer Terry Walsh
      • http://intensedebate.com/people/urmaster urmaster

        I don't think that does DVB-T2???

        • http://intensedebate.com/people/tezzer Terry Walsh

          It doesn't – DVB-T only

  • Chris

    Bingo! I knew at some point you'd listen to me. I kept mentioning this ;) (I can't remember how it was I logged in here, so maybe different this time) One big perk of using HDHomeRun to a virtualized MCE for your tuning isn't mentioned here but should be: CPU Usage with an HDHomeRun is significantly less then with a traditional tuner. This makes a big difference for those not wanting to mount up monster CPUs in a home server.

  • sheroo

    I still think that the dvblogic software is better than these hd homeruns for people in the UK. It will support dvb-t2 when available, and already supports dvb-s2.
    You can use your existing tuners all for the price of 40 euros. I have been running a tuner farm for a few months now, and will never go back…

  • jfro

    Any suspend or wake feature to save power?

  • nope

    to hell with this, i going to get one. loosers

  • Bauersachs

    My personal tip is the new Mystique SaTiX-S2 Sky , a PCI card, DVB-S2 (HDTV, MPEG4), which seamless integrates into SuSe (my version 11.1) and VDR system (with VDPAU). Also tested in Windows Media Center, W7, 64Bit … direct integration. Thumbs up