Axigen Mail Server Mini-Review

The Groupware function presents Public Folders which allow for the sharing of Message, Contact and Calendar information. It is also possible for a user to elect to share any of their personal folders as well. Full Outlook integrations as well as iCalendar functionality is refreshing to see in a product of this class.

Rules and filters can be applied to inbound messages on the server and it appears there is a capability for the user to exert some control through the Web Mail interface. However, the review version appears to be presenting a ‘Technology Preview’ version and had this area disabled.

Further screenshots of the Web Mail interface are here:-

screenshot.70 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.71 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review

screenshot.73 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.74 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.75 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.76 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.77 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.78 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.79 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.80 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review screenshot.81 thumb Axigen Mail Server Mini Review

I am not sure why, but when an icon for Calendar, Contacts, Journal, Notes or Tasks is clicked in Web Mail, it opens a new window.

The optional ActiveSync capability was an area I was unable to test as I do not have access to any of the compatible mobile devices. However, judging from comments ion the Forums, this is a welcome additional capability at a reasonable annual licence charge.

Axigen is available with both AV and spam filtering. ClamAV and SpamAssassin are built-in and just require enabling if required. Commtouch is a more advanced spam filter and is available on subscription. There are also Whitelists, Blacklists, Sender Policies and Country filtering available. All these options provide for comprehensive protection, but are indicative of just how difficult it is currently to run and maintain a safe and secure email server.

There are also a range of logging and reporting options for those that want to track what is going on in the background.

The problem with trying to review something like a mail server is that you really need to look at how the package works over time. With an already working email server on my primary WHS limits how much real throughput I can pass through a test system without disrupting the family.  Hence, my summary stems from ‘would I consider Axigen as a replacement for my existing mail server’? I think the answer has to be yes. It is feature rich and while you do not get the WHS Console integration that is available with VPOP3, the more advanced configuration with that package has to be performed through a web-admin interface. A few weeks use as a primary mail server will tell me more on how easy it is to live with in the longer term. I am certainly looking forward to having a functional IMAP system which will allow me to use both Outlook and Web clients efficiently.

In summary, Axigen Mail Server is a comprehensive, professional-grade product which will certainly service the needs of  the WHS user. The lack of management via the Console is not an issue as the Web Admin is comprehensive. However, as a result it lacks account integration but for up to 10 users, this should not cause a significant admin headache. The downsides are that its complexity can prove daunting for the average home user. The fetching of POP3 mail from an ISP has to be set up on a user by user basis through their individual Web Mail interfaces. This is not particularly problematic, but it would be nice to see an option to do this centrally and in particular to handle a catch-all POP3 account to save setting up multiple individual configurations.

As a Windows application, it should have made the necessary changes to the Windows firewall during installation. There are no warnings to the user and the initial symptoms would that it was not working. Also, the lack of checks for anything else on the chosen ports can cause issues. Integration on IIS would be a nice option as it would allow presentation of a single front-end interface to the web user. It is possible to add links to the WHS home page to both web mail and web admin through WHS Add-ins like Whiist, but to allow use from the internet will require further port forwarding rules on the home router. That said, users who have the need to set up a mail server and the understanding of the implications of managing such a system should be able to cover off these issues.


Enjoyed this post? Share it.

If you enjoyed reading this post, then why not share it with your friends and followers?

About Dave Marchant

For me, Windows Home Server is very much a hobby as well as a very useful addition to the home computer network. I have been in the computer industry since the embryonic days of microprocessors having designed with some of the original 8-bit devices. In the past I have worked as UK Support Manager for a major PC manufacturer and I am currently IT Manager for a major Microsoft Gold Partner in the Business Products arena.

Sign Up for WGS Daily News

If you don't want to miss out on the latest news from We Got Served, why not subscribe to our daily digest? You'll get the day's headlines and a short summary of each news item delivered straight to your inbox each morning.

, , , , , ,

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/urmaster urmaster

    Dave nice review, I'll be looking into this, any idea how to configure this mail server for php?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      Searching for 'php' in their documentation and knowledgebase doesn't throw up anything that looks useful. It looks like the web server may be embedded within the application.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/urmaster urmaster

        in that case I'm guessing there's something in php I need to configure to get it working with this ^_-

  • Mats

    I use and recommend smartermail from smartertools. It got 10 user account and 1 domain for free.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/urmaster urmaster

      Is this easy to setup on WHS or Win 7?

    • Scott

      Can you set up storage of e mails to the pool drives so you don't overload the sys drive?

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

        You can set up the location of the data area but I am not sure I would advise putting it in the pool. You could use a non-pooled folder on the D: drive or a separate drive completely. With programs that dynamically change data, (uTorrent for example) I am still wary about submitting them to Drive Extender.

    • T-Bone

      Im suprised no one has made and add in interface for Smarter mail. I have looked over the youtube video and it looked nice. as for the WHS tutorial it is out of date I tried to use that a while back but the newer version has a few more options and screens are a little diffrent.

    • http://www.worldofwatches.com Amber

      Where I can download smartemail? can you please link it.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/urmaster urmaster

    hmm those ports might wreak havok for Twonkey and SqueezeBox server owners (me). What is it with web applications and port 9000?

    No chance of changing the port?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      The Axigen Web Admin port is configurable during initial setup. 9000 is the default, but you can pick anything you like.

  • http://www.cybergamers.nl GaMeR

    It's cool to see my work is appreciated. :)

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      You ought to get 50% of the credit as I left out the detailed install stuff that would normally go in – it was all there in the Wiki.

      • Duane

        I have to agree with Dave. I used his Wiki on how to set this up and the directions are excellent.

  • Scott

    Dave,
    In your review you mentioned that you were already using another mail server as your primary, what is it and are you happy with it?
    Also, if I want to use myname@myhomeserver.homeserver.com to get e mail, will axigen set this up for me? Is this safe to open your server up like this to receive e mails from the internet?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      I am currently using VPOP3 for all the family's email on my main server. This is the only one around currently that has a WHS interface for a lot of the admin. The WHS version does have some limitations though and I was interested to see how Axigen compared – quite favorably). I have seen reports that if you open port 25 through the router to your WHS running a mail server program, you should receive emails to your domain account (this is going to be some more testing for me though). I may knock out a quck review of VPOP3 while I am still running it as it is perfectly acceptable within its limits.

      • Scott

        Just so I understand, if I open port 25 I can receive e mails on the domain name I created for free when I set up my home server? Does VPOP3 allow this function?
        Do I need extra security or anti virus? I currently run the avast for antivirus.

        • Scott

          Looking at VPOP3, I need an ISP to host e mail services. I guess I am looking for something else. I am looking to use my WHS to host my own e mail services to be comepltely independent of any provider. I want to be able to pick up my server and move it to any ISP and carry my e mail with me. Do any of the current e mail programs allow this?

        • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

          I am led to believe that will work, but I haven't tested it myself. Currently I fetch all my email from my ISP's using POP3. VPOP3 certainly will run as an SMTP server accepting email on port 25. You should have AV checking as a minimum and Avast will check the messages as they are written into the user's mailboxes. If you are accepting email direct, subscribing to VPOP3 (or Axigen's) spam filtering is probably a good bet too.

          • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

            Confirmed this morning that both VPOP3 and Axigen will accept SMTP email sent to name@xxx.homeserver.com. Both needed a little bit of config – Axigen more than VPOP3.

  • Duane

    Dave,

    I believe the reason the calendar, tasks, jounal, and notes open in a new window is because those functions use a different interface. Those appear to use the standard interface while the mail itself uses the Ajax interface.

    You can set the option in the webmail (on the admin side) so users can use both interfaces, or either the standard or Ajax interface. You can also set one of them as the default.

    I have been using Axigen for a while now and really like it. The only issue I have run into is with the new version the timestamp on the messages received in the webmail are incorrect. There are settings for the timezone and alll have been set correclty on both the admin and user side.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      Which version has the timestamp issues. I only did limited tests on this and did not notice anything on 7.3.3.

      • Duane

        I am using version 7.3.2. It appears that it only happens at certain times. Usually it will stat around 6-8 PM EST time.

        Here is a link of a screenshot that shows you the problem.

        http://www.screencast.com/users/dman109/folders/J

        Maybe in 7.3.3 it has been fixed.

        • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

          There is nothing in the Release Notes for 7.3.3 to suggest that is an area that has been changed. I'll look out for it as I do an extended test over the coming weeks.

  • Jason

    How does Smartermail compare to Kerio? Am running Kerio, but it seems like overkill. Seems to have a larger footprint, more resource intensive.

  • http://www.zonderdank.be Cyberke

    I installed the mailserver yesterday but I can't get any mail coming in on my name@XXX.homeserver.com, the remote pop3 function works great. Now I still have to figure out how to connect my thunderbird to the server. When I use the WHS servername or IP address as pop3 server, I always get a connection timeout error. Firewall on the WHS server is off and the necessary ports are forwarded in my pfsense proxy/router.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

      I have set up Axigen to work on inbound SMTP this morning to check some things for you. I have mail coming in to the server from name@xxx.homeserver.com. I put my server's IP address into the SMTP Receivers Listening section explicitly (not sure if that was totally needed). It wasn't delivering to the mailbox though but holding messages in the queue as I hadn't configured ClamAV or SpamAssassin correctly. I disabled them and the message came through. Check the Queue and also the Log Files in the Web Admin console for clues. Also have you enabled the POP3 Server on Axigen and the mail account.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

        On the POP3 Server settings check the authentication that is configured as well. You may need to select other options to get yourself connected.

    • Duane

      If you still have trouble getting mail after making the changes Dave suggested, it may be that your ISP is blocking you. To test it, log into your server and open a command prompt.
      Type the following: telnet xxx.homeserver.com 25.

      If the test is successful you will see: 220 your server name Axigen ESMTP Ready.

    • http://www.zonderdank.be Cyberke

      Thank you for the information. I tried to telnet and I got the mailserver is ready response, so this means that my ISP isn't blocking port 25? Now I am still stuck receiving e-mails on my name@xxx.homeserver.com account. If you say you have to add the servers IP to the smtp listeners, which IP do you mean exactly and do I use port 25 for it? I tried to introduce my external IP address but the mailserver says it is not legal. Then I tried my internal WHS IP address, which is accepted but doesn't change anything.

      Would it be possible to list the ports that need to be forwarded to the WHS and explain me a bit more in detail the config tweaking that is needed?

      A very big thank you!

      Nic

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

        I added the server's actual IP address, not the external one, to the SMTP listeners. If you are getting the 220 response, tyou should be able to get messages delivered to the queue – check the Queue in the Web Admin. Mine sat in the Queue due to bad configuration of the AV.

      • Duane

        In the SMTP listeners section, you would add your servers internal IP address (192.168.1.1). Is the listener enabled? You should see a status next to the IP address on the main screen. If you had to add a new listener by default it isn't enabled. You can enable it from the main listners screen.

    • http://www.zonderdank.be Cyberke

      I sent an email to my name@xxx.homeserver.com address and I got this error:
      The mail system

      <name@xxx.homeserver.com>: connect to
      xxx.homeserver.com[192.168.0.100]: Connection timed out

      Reporting-MTA: dns; yorgi.telenet-ops.be
      X-Postfix-Queue-ID: 0054268242C
      X-Postfix-Sender: rfc822; name@telenet.be
      Arrival-Date: Thu, 1 Apr 2010 15:21:23 +0200 (CEST)

      Final-Recipient: rfc822; name@xxx.homeserver.com
      Original-Recipient: rfc822;name@xxx.homeserver.com
      Action: failed
      Status: 4.4.1
      Diagnostic-Code: X-Postfix; connect to
      xxx.homeserver.com[192.168.0.100]: Connection timed out

      Any ideas?

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Dave_Marchant Dave_Marchant

        You may still have something blocking receipt of messages within Axigen. Is there anything in the Axigen logs that indicates what or why as it looks like a conversation with the server was started.

        To save this getting too long and technical here, we may be better off taking this over to the forum – try a reply post here – http://forum.wegotserved.com/index.php?/topic/775

        • http://www.zonderdank.be Cyberke

          I don't think it would be necessary to go to the forums, because suddenly this morning it was working. I received all previous sent mails on my naam@xxx.homeserver.com mailaccount.

          Thank you all for the help and the info!

          Nic

  • http://www.frugalgal.org John

    Looks great considering that their 5 user package is FREE! I would probably try this one for a home business mail server. =)

    • Jerry

      Is this truly free or an evaluation? I hate the word FREE and then it turns to FEE. Rather than call it free it should be called a trial.

      Can someone email me and advise if this is truly FREE!

      jerryhollis@gmx.com

  • Jerry

    During an install of 7.33 I noticed there was text that stated this was good for 30 days only! Then you would be prompted to one of the other plans if you wished to keep it "alive".

    Confirm or deny?

    jerryhollis@gmx.com

  • Jerry

    From what I can gather even the Free edition is only free for one year….

  • Jerry

    I could never get a setting that worked to relay messages. I guess it works fine if you just want to recieve but never reply :-)