Add-In Review: Home Server SMART

Mon, Jan 25, 2010

  |  Jim Clark

S.M.A.R.T. is short for Self-Monitoring, Analysis, and Reporting Technology for computer hard disks.  As a Windows Home Server is, well, a server, the drives inside one are the most important single entity of a WHS.  The problem is: how does one determine the S.M.A.R.T. health status of a WHS hard disk?

The answer to that question is this add-in called Home Server SMART.  A WHS utility that should have been part of the WHS add-in arsenal quite some time ago.

Installing the add-in is as simple as any other add-in.  Copy the msi installer to your D:SoftwareAdd-ins folder, open the WHS Setting Window in the console and install the software from the Add-ins tab, as shown below.

SM1 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM2 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Reopen the WHS console, locate and click on the Home Server SMART tab.  At first, there is nothing to see other than a listing of the drives in your system.

SM4 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Simply highlight a drive to get a listing of the drive information and S.M.A.R.T. details

SM5 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Once you have highlighted a drive, you may then click on the SMART Status option along the top of  the window.  The following shows a drive with Warning status.

 SM6 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM7 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

A drive with a Healthy status.

SM8 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM9 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

A drive with a Critical status.  Me thinks I need to keep a close eye on this drive!

SM10 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM11 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Clicking on the Quick Help option brings up general program help and SMART information.

SM12 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM13 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Finally, clicking on Refresh Disks will simply refresh the attached disk drives and associated information screens.

SM14 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

That’s all there is to the program.  Nothing more and nothing less is needed for this program, with the possible exception of a continuous monitoring/alert option if something starts going bad.

There is one other item that needs verification.  Is the reported information correct/accurate?  I went to my favorite benchmark website, Passmark Software, and downloaded their DiskCheckup software, which uses the same SMART information as Home Server SMART.

I installed it, opened it,

SM15 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

and checked the data from one program to the other.

SM16 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM17 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART SM18 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

Everything that I saw seemed to agree, which gives me that warm comfy feeling that comes from verification.  The last picture gives you an idea of what each SMART item represents, which is basically a duplicate of the Home Server SMART help file info.

SM19 thumb Add In Review: Home Server SMART

The dividing line between one program and another is the interpretation of the Reallocated Sector Count.  While Home Server SMART interpreted the raw data of my 4th drives as critical, DiskCheckup did not.  I tend to agree that 53 reallocated sectors is probably not a good thing.

My verdict of Home Server SMART?  Highly recommended!  As I indicated above, a continuous monitoring/alert option would be a nice program enhancement.

Developer: Dojo North Software

Version Reviewed: 1.0.1.21

Release: 21Jan2010

More Info: Download | Support Forum

 

Similar Posts:

This post was written by:

Jim Clark - who has written 268 posts on We Got Served.

Hello. I’m from the heartland of U.S. Lots of corn and beans, although Iowa is a lot more than just farmland. It also has a few computer enthusiasts (no, not me!). I’ve been around PC’s since I got my 1st PC XT aloooong time ago. WGS is one of the first sites I found centered around WHS. And the best. Every once in awhile, I do get away from the KB and enjoy time with and my wife and our 4 kids. And I do have a day job.

Contact the author

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

6 Responses to “Add-In Review: Home Server SMART”

  1. MRL_WHS Says:

    I like the idea of this add-in due to past experience with drives failing and WHS giving NO warning. Will this trigger the WHS Health indicator? Read the first line of the help file. "Exceptions were detected loading the help file; using internal text." Same in the image above. Not sure what that's about. I installed it on my test server and all went well. More to come…

    Reply

  2. urmaster Says:

    Just like MRL_WHS has pointed out great for actually getting the info WHS fails to report.

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The Home Server Show 74 : Home Server Show - 28. Jan, 2010

    [...] Home Server Smart [...]

  2. Home Server Show Podcast 74 Out Now | Using Windows Home Server - 28. Jan, 2010

    [...] Home Server Smart [...]

  3. Windows Home Server Hard Drive Failure — The OS Quest - 02. Feb, 2010

    [...] more information about the Home Server Smart Add-in you can see the reviews at HomeServerLand or We Got Served. No sense me repeating their review. I’ll just add my endorsement of the plug in. It’s a simple [...]

  4. Windows Homes Server Add-Ins — The OS Quest - 13. Mar, 2010

    [...] drive problems with my Windows Home Server. It made it easy for me to find the problem hard drive. We Got Served has a in-depth and accurate review of this [...]

Leave a Reply